Suspected Algorithm Bias? Tenant Rights in Germany

Algorithmic decisions can have major consequences in renting: listings, credit checks or automatic rent adjustments often use algorithms that may cause unintended disadvantages. As a tenant in Germany, it is important to recognise when algorithm bias could be present and which steps are available to defend your rights. This article explains clearly how to check for distortions, which official forms you can use and how a sample letter to landlords or authorities should be written. You will receive practical options — from documentation and data protection complaints to lawsuits at the local court — and guidance on which laws such as the BGB or the AGG are relevant. The goal is to give you clear, actionable steps.

What is algorithm bias in the rental context?

Algorithm bias means systematic distortions in automated decisions. In housing, this can mean that certain groups are disadvantaged in listings, credit checks or preselection processes. Such effects can arise unintentionally from training data, weighting or model assumptions. Legally, contractual duties and protection laws may apply; for tenancy claims, the provisions of the German Civil Code (BGB) are primarily relevant^[1], and the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG) may apply if discrimination based on protected characteristics occurs^[2].

Checklist and actions

• Document results: screenshots, exact times and notes of conversations.
• Collect the tenancy agreement, copies of forms and proof of payments as evidence.
• Draft a sample letter to the landlord or platform operator naming the contested decision.
• Submit a complaint to the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection in case of data protection breaches^[3].
• Consider clarification before the competent local court if out-of-court steps fail.

About the sample letter: specify the concrete incident, attach evidence and request a written explanation as well as correction or deletion of the automated decision. Send the letter preferably by registered post or by email with read receipt. If the other party does not respond, set deadlines and consider legal action.

FAQ

Can I challenge an automatic rejection of a housing application?

Yes. First collect evidence and request a concrete reason. If the rejection was caused by discriminatory criteria or incorrect data, you can demand correction and, if necessary, take legal action.

Does the landlord have to explain how their algorithm works?

There is no general obligation to disclose source code, but you have rights to information about the data used and the reasons for the decision under data protection law and possibly transparency obligations.

Which authorities are responsible?

Data protection issues are handled by the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection or the state data protection authorities; tenancy disputes are dealt with by the local court.

How-To

1. Gather evidence: screenshots, date/time, conversation notes and contract copies.
2. Write a sample letter: name the incident, attach evidence and request a written statement.
3. Submit a data protection complaint to the Federal Commissioner and request information about your data^[3].
4. Consider legal action: if necessary, file a claim at the competent local court.

Key takeaways

• Good documentation is the basis of any complaint.
• Observe deadlines and respond promptly to letters.
• The local court is the correct instance for many tenancy disputes.

Help and Support / Resources

• German Civil Code (BGB) – gesetze-im-internet.de
• General Equal Treatment Act (AGG) – gesetze-im-internet.de
• Federal Commissioner for Data Protection – Forms

---

1. [1] German Civil Code (BGB) — gesetze-im-internet.de
2. [2] General Equal Treatment Act (AGG) — gesetze-im-internet.de
3. [3] Federal Commissioner for Data Protection — Forms