Hardship Objection in Old Buildings: Tenant Rights Germany

Many tenants in Germany, especially in shared flats and old buildings, face the hardship objection: how to review rent reductions, modernization notices or evictions legally without making mistakes. This guide explains in plain language which formal deadlines apply, which documents matter and how to avoid typical errors such as missing evidence, incorrect deadlines or unclear wording. I give practical steps for documenting defects, communicating with the landlord correctly and when going to the local court or seeking local authority advice makes sense. I also list official forms and links to relevant BGB paragraphs so you immediately know which steps are legally sound.

What is a hardship objection?

The hardship objection is not a separate paragraph but a legal protection concept allowing tenants in special cases to challenge evictions, modernizations or unreasonable burdens. Key are the assessment of reasonableness, concrete impairments of residential use and classification under tenancy law rules, in particular the BGB provisions on tenant duties and defects^[1].

Common mistakes and how to avoid them

• Missing documentation: photos and dates are absent
• Overlooked deadlines: response and reduction deadlines not met
• Unclear or missing written notification to the landlord
• Incorrect calculation of rent reduction or deductions

Especially in shared flats there are extra questions: who signs letters, how are deductions shared and what do sublease agreements state? Assign internal responsibilities and document who reported what and when. If a lawsuit becomes necessary, the local court is usually responsible for tenancy disputes at the place of residence^[2].

Forms and court procedure

Important official forms include the application for legal aid (Prozesskostenhilfe, PKH) if litigation costs are too high, and Beratungshilfe for brief legal assistance. A typical example: a shared flat documents mold, informs the landlord in writing and applies for Beratungshilfe before starting court proceedings. PKH is applied for in writing to the competent court and requires information on income and assets^[3].

FAQ

What can I do if the landlord announces a modernization?

Check the notice in writing, document the apartment condition and cost consequences, and seek legal advice if necessary. In doubtful cases a hardship objection against eviction or implementation can be considered.

Which deadlines must I observe for defects?

Defects should be reported in writing immediately; there are no fixed deadlines for rent reduction, but delays weaken your evidence.

When is it worthwhile to apply for legal aid (PKH)?

If the costs of proceedings exceed your financial means, apply for PKH; the court will check income and assets.

How-To

1. Check deadlines and note appointments
2. Document defects: take photos, note dates and keep logs
3. Inform the landlord in writing and set a clear deadline
4. Calculate legal consequences: state rent reduction correctly
5. If needed, file a claim or apply for PKH

Key takeaways

• Good documentation increases chances of success in disputes.
• Meeting deadlines is often decisive for your claim.
• Forms like PKH and Beratungshilfe can reduce court costs.

Help and Support

• BGB (§§ 535–536) - Gesetze im Internet
• Local Court - Justizportal
• Legal Aid (PKH) - BMJ

---

1. [1] BGB (§§ 535–536) - Gesetze im Internet
2. [2] Local Court - Justizportal
3. [3] Legal Aid (PKH) - BMJ